Business and premises owners recently received some good news from the Michigan Supreme Court.
On April 14, the Supreme Court ruled in the case of Ragnoli v North Oakland-North Macomb Imaging, Inc. that:
“notwithstanding low lighting in the parking lot, the presence of wintry weather
conditions and of ice on the ground elsewhere in the premises rendered the
risk of a black ice patch “open and obvious such that a reasonably prudent
person would foresee the danger” of slipping and falling in the parking lot.”
In rendering its decision in Ragnoli, the Supreme Court reversed a previously unpublished Michigan Court of Appeals ruling, which had reversed the trial court’s granting of a motion for summary disposition indicating that there were questions of fact as to whether the black ice was open and obvious given evidence of poor lighting.
While premises owners must always maintain safe conditions, the Supreme Court’s ruling reinforces the notion that ice and snow are open and obvious during cold and wintry seasons.
Christopher J. Scott is a partner in the firm's Flint office who focuses his practice in all areas of law concerning personal injury, property damage or commercial liability, including premises liability, construction ...
Add a comment
SubscribeRSS Plunkett Cooney LinkedIn Page Plunkett Cooney Twitter Page Plunkett Cooney Facebook Page
- Premises Liability
- Litigation Discovery
- Commercial Real Estate
- Retail Liability
- Open & Obvious Doctrine
- Open & Obvious
- Snow & Ice Claims
- Risk Management
- Liquor Liability
- Residential Liability
- Business Risk Management
- Real Estate
- FDA Regulations
- Food Law
- Foodservice & Hospitality
- Regulatory Law
- Constructive Notice
- Governmental Immunity
- Motor Vehicle Liability
- New Supreme Court Discovery Rule Places Emphasis on Proportionality Over Relevance
- Court Reinforces Principle That Landowners Generally Have no Duty to Prevent Criminal Acts
- Don't Drink and File... a Lawsuit
- Michigan Court of Appeals Affirms Black Ice Remains Open and Obvious
- Phantom Employees Create a 'Question of Fact' for Notice Defense
- Social Media can Derail Defense of Your Premises Liability Case
- The Down and Dirty on Manufacturing Clean Foods, Using Clean Labeling
- Heads up! Baseball, Hotdogs and… Personal Risk at the Ball Park?
- Court Reluctantly Confirms Open and Obvious Doctrine in Ordinary Negligence Claims Involving Snow and Ice
- Low Light and Black Ice Does Not Avoid Open and Obvious