Publications
PDFWashington Coverage Update
Fee and Cost Awards - Washington
Shiferaw v. Nationwide Affinity Ins. Co. of Am.
No. 39643-6-III, --- P.3d ---, 2026 WL 3402864 (Wash. Ct. App. Nov. 10, 2026)
In August 2017, Meseret Shiferaw (Shiferaw) drove through a stop sign in Alberta, Canada, and was hit by a semi-truck driven by Paul Coyle. She and her husband Solomon Agere (Agere) were seriously injured, and their three children died. Shiferaw had a Washington-issued personal auto policy with Nationwide Affinity Insurance Company of America (Nationwide). The policy’s out-of-state clause raised Shiferaw’s liability limits to Alberta’s $200,000 minimum requirement for third-party liability coverage. Nationwide paid collision, Underinsured Motorist (UIM) and Personal Injury Protection (PIP) benefits to Shiferaw, but determined that Shiferaw was at fault for the accident and that the claims would exceed her limits.
Agere demanded policy limits from Nationwide to compensate himself and for the estates of his children. Coyle’s claim was still open under Alberta’s two-year limitation period, but he did not make a formal settlement demand to Shiferaw or Nationwide. Nationwide wanted a global resolution of all claims and declined to settle the intrafamily claims or agree to a tolling agreement, reasoning that paying one claimant would end its defense obligations and leave Shiferaw exposed. Agere sued Shiferaw in Spokane County, Washington in August 2019 and added Nationwide as a defendant the next day. Shiferaw then brought crossclaims against Nationwide for (1) violation of the Insurance Fair Conduct Act (IFCA), (2) breach of the duty of good faith, (3) violation of the Consumer Protection Act (CPA) and (4) negligence.
The trial court ordered Nationwide to pay the $200,000 limit to Agere. Agere and Shiferaw then went to binding arbitration, which produced an award of approximately $17.1 million. Nationwide paid the full award, and Agere released his claims. At trial, the jury found that Nationwide: (1) violated the IFCA, (2) breached the duty of good faith, (3) violated the CPA and (4) was negligent. It awarded Shiferaw $27,136,000 in total compensatory damages, $27 million in noneconomic damages, and $47 million in punitive damages for common law bad faith under Ohio law. It also found that Nationwide was liable for the reasonable attorney fees. After IFCA enhancement and attorney fees with a two-times multiplier, the judgment totaled approximately $103.2 million. Nationwide appealed.
On appeal, the Court of Appeals of Washington held that the IFCA claim failed as a matter of law because (1) Nationwide paid all contractual benefits before the notice-and-cure period began, (2) the benefits at issue were third-party liability payments and (3) the IFCA requires an unreasonable denial of coverage or benefits rather than mere delay. The appellate court reasoned that Nationwide’s payment of the $200,000 limit months before Shiferaw’s IFCA notice “resolved the basis” for the claim under the statute’s 20-day safe-harbor provision, that the later $17.1 million arbitration award was extracontractual liability outside IFCA’s reach, and that IFCA does not reach an insured’s complaint about the timing of payment to a third-party claimant. It further held that the trial court’s “delayed or denied” jury instruction impermissibly expanded the statute, which the Washington Legislature deliberately stripped of “delay” language, and declined to follow contrary federal decisions as nonbinding and distinguishable.
The appellate court reversed the punitive damages award, reasoning that even if Ohio law applied, the evidence did not show actual malice by clear and convincing evidence and Washington law, which applied to punitive damages, does not allow common law punitive damages.
The appellate court further held that denying a new trial was not an abuse of discretion and vacated all fee and cost awards. In sum, the appellate court affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded the trial court’s order. The appellate court affirmed the bad faith, negligence and CPA awards, and the denial of a new trial. It reversed the IFCA award, with the claim to be dismissed with prejudice, and the $47 million punitive damages award. It remanded for a fresh determination of fees and costs, and for reconsideration of injunctive relief under the CPA.